Ethical Dimensions of College and University Teaching:
Understanding
and Honoring the Special Relationship Between Teachers and
Students
Edited by Linc. Fisch
(New Directions for Teaching and Learning, No. 66)
San Francisco: Jossey-Bass Publishers, 1996.
Linc. Fisch introduces this collection by arguing that while most college and university teachers know the "rules" of ethics
in the academy--"it is commitment to those rules and ideals that is necessary for the ethical professoriate"--and that
preparation to meet ethical dilemmas requires "an ever deeper awareness of the
subtleties
of application of ethical principles and an understanding
of the gray
areas between what is ethical and what is not ethical."
No doubt
he is right. In the nineties as never before, we find
ourselves
confronting situations which our counterparts of a
generation ago
would not have faced or would have simply
ignored. To
help meet this challenge, the collections's 13 essays
address the
"ethical dimensions" of our lives as teachers: "The Ethics
of
Teaching," by David C. Smith; "Teaching the Subject:
Developmental
Identities in Teaching," by Mary Burgan; "The Ethics of
Student-Faculty Friendships," by Richard L. Baker, Jr.;
"Between
Apathy and Advocacy: Teaching and Modeling Ethical
Reflection," by
Karen Hanson; "Institutional Commitment to Fairness in
College
Teaching," by Rita Cobb Rodobaugh; "Differentiating the
Related
Concepts of Ethics, Morality, Law, and Justice," by Terry T.
Ray;
"The Ethics of Knowledge," by Clark Kerr; "Ethical
Principles for
College and University Teaching," by Harry Murray and
others; "Making
Responsible Academic and Ethical Decisions," by Charles H.
Reynolds;
"Intervening with Colleagues," by Patricia Keith-Spiegel and
others,
"Reflecting on the Ethics and Values of Our Practice," by
Ronald A.
Smith; "Toward More Ethical Teaching," by Linc. Fisch; and
"Ethics in
Teaching: Putting it Together," by Kathleen McGrory.
Perhaps the most enlightening list of the
responsibilities of the
ethical teacher appear in "Ethical Principles for College
and
University Teaching," material originally disseminated by
the Society
for Teaching and Learning in Higher Education:
- Principle 1: Content Competence
A university teacher maintains a high level of subject
matter
knowledge and ensures that course content is current,
accurate,
representative, and appropriate to the position of the
course within
the student's program of studies.
- Principle 2: Pedagogical Competence
A pedagogically competent teacher communicates the
objectives of the
course to students, is aware of alternative instructional
methods or
strategies, and selects methods of instruction that,
according to
research evidence (including personal or self-reflective
research),
are effective in helping students to achieve the course
objectives.
- Principle 3: Dealing with Sensitive Topics
Topics that students are likely to find sensitive or
discomforting
are dealt with in an open, honest, and positive way.
- Principle 4: Student Development
The overriding responsibility of the teacher is to
contribute to the
intellectual development of the student, at least in the
context of
the teacher's own area of expertise, and to avoid actions
such as
exploitation and discrimination that detract from student
development.
- Principle 5: Dual Relationships with Students
To avoid conflict of interest, a teacher does not enter
into
dual-role relationships with students that are likely to
detract from
student development or lead to actual or perceived
favoritism on the
part of the teacher.
- Principle 6: Confidentiality
Student grades, attendance records, and private
communications are
treated as confidential materials and are released only
with student
consent, for legitimate academic purposes, or if there are
reasonable
grounds for believing that releasing such information will
be
beneficial to the student or will prevent harm to others.
- Principle 7: Respect for Colleagues
A university teacher respects the dignity of her or his
colleagues
and works cooperatively with colleagues in the interest of
fostering
student development.
- Principle 8: Valid Assessment of Students
Given the importance of assessment of student performance
in
university teaching and in students' lives and careers,
instructors
are responsible for taking adequate steps to ensure that
assessment
of students is valid, open, fair, and congruent with course
objectives.
- Principle 9: Respect for Institution
In the interests of student development, a university
teacher is
aware of and respects the educational goals, policies, and
standards
of the institution in which he or she teaches. (Murray,
et. al.).
I find myself, however, returning to Linc. Fisch's
opening
remarks. Knowledge and commitment to the ethics of our
profession
are indeed prerequisites for handling ethical dilemmas
well. But it
seems unlikely that the book will be read broadly by the
populations
that could use it the most. It will not, that is, convert
anyone to
the importance of ethical teaching behaviors. Instead (as my
mother would say), it is "preaching to the choir": a book
that will
be read by the already-converted. Nonetheless, it is
likely to
increase our sensitivity to issues that we might not have
defined as
ethical ones and even to provide us with possible solutions
to the
problems we are already facing as teachers.
As Kathleen McGrory writes, "a basic premise of this
volume is
that the quality of faculty moral decision making can be
improved by
increased self-awareness and sensitivity to the rights of
students,
and by doing some `homework'" (106). In order to broaden
the
audience of the message, perhaps we need (as Linc. Fisch
suggests) to
find creative ways to confront the ethics of teaching as a
faculty
development issue.
Nancy Warner Barrineau
UNC at Pembroke